Listen, we all know that family comes first. Except in the court of law! Antigone buried her brother knowing that she was going to get punished for this crime. She may have thought she was being loyal to her family by burying her brother, but she was being disrespectful and disloyal to her uncle Creon, our king. Because Creon violated the laws of the state I have no choice but to prosecute her for her crime.
Antigone knew what she was getting into from the beginning. She knew that she would get prosecuted for such a crime, but carried through anyways. This is shown in paragraph 5. "For Creon this mater's really serious. Anyone who acts against the order will be stoned to death before the city." Therefore the consequences must stand. We can't let crimes like this just slip by. We need to show that we have a strong economy; when people are breaking laws like this, they must be punished.
Antigone even tried to get her sister, Ismene, involved with her plan to bury Polyneices. Ismene had some common sense and refused to help her sister. This is shown in paragraph 16. "I'm not disrespecting them. But i can't act against the state. That's not im my nature." She knew the punishments and the dangers of breaking the law.
I understand that Antigone was just trying to bury her brother because she was staying loyal to her family. But at the same time she wasn't being loyal to her family, because her uncle is our king, Creon. This shows disrespect and unforgivable sin. She needs to learn from her wrong doings and be punished for the things she has done.
Antigone buried her brother even though he was going against their own city, Thebes. She knew the consequences of what she was doing but ignored them. She disrespected her family and even tried to get her sister involved with burying Polyneices. Because Antigone violated the laws of the state, I find her guilty for burying her brother.
Friday, November 28, 2008
LRJ #2 - Antigone
- Antigone wants to have a proper burial for her brother, Polyneices, but she can't bury him because he was fighting against their city, Thebes. She carried through with it anyways and now Creon could kill her for it. Antigone is perceived as a very strong and stubborn woman, but also shows her loyal, and courageous care for her family. Lines 118-119 on page 824 show how she cares for her brother even though he went against their city. "It is my nature to join in love, not hate." Antigone really does not care what happens to her because she knows that what she is doing is right. This is shown in lines 107-108 on page 824. "There is no guilt in reverence of the dead."
- Antigone's fatal flaw was that she chose to bury her brother, because even though she thought she was doing the right thing, she would be vanquished from the city because of it. Her stubbornness led up to this because she refused stop at trying to get her brother buried. This is shown throughout many quotes in the story such as page 824, lines 107-108. "If that is what you think, I should not want you, even if you ask to come. You have made your choice and you can be what you want to be; but I will burry him; but if I must die, I say that this crime is holy: I shall lie down with him in death, and I shall be as dear to him as he to me. Not the living who makes the longest demands. We die forever. You may do ask you like, since apparently the laws of the gods mean nothing to you."
- Antigone's anagnorisis is that she realizes that even though her uncle is the king, he still will not cut her any slack for her trying to bury Polyneices. He will still kill her no matter what. This is shown in paragraph 242. "O city of my fathers in the land of Thebe! O ye gods, eldest of our race!-they lead me henc--now, now-they tarry not! Behold me, princes of Thebes, the last daughter of the house of your kings,-see what I suffer, and from whom, because I feared to cast away the fear of Heaven!"
- Antigone's Peripeteia happens when she kills herself because she knew that the after life would be better than starving in a dark, cold, cave. She knew she was going to die for this crime all along, so rather than suffer. She decided to end her life right away. There was nothing else to live for and she was going to die anyway.
- The audience has a catharsis when Antigone is about to be sent off to the cave where she will starve. The audience is not sure what Creon is going to do with her and it is quite suspenseful. When the audience finds out that she will be sent off to a cave to starve, they feel very bad for her because she was only trying to do good. She does not deserve such harsh punishment because she was staying loyal to her family. This is shown in paragraph 235. "Tomb, bridal-chamber, eternal prison in the caverned rock, whither go to find mine own, those many who have perished, and whom Persephone hath received among the dead!"
- In Antigone, women seem portrayed as weak characters. There appears be the vibe that women cannot do anything on their own and they always need help from men. This is shown in when Haemon says this quote in paragraph 197, "If thou art a woman; indeed, my care is for thee." Even Ismene talks about how women should not fight against men because they would lose. This is shown in paragraph 16. " Nay, we must remember, first, that we were born women, as who should not strive with men;"
- Antigone's fatal flaw was that she chose to bury her brother, because even though she thought she was doing the right thing, she would be vanquished from the city because of it. Her stubbornness led up to this because she refused stop at trying to get her brother buried. This is shown throughout many quotes in the story such as page 824, lines 107-108. "If that is what you think, I should not want you, even if you ask to come. You have made your choice and you can be what you want to be; but I will burry him; but if I must die, I say that this crime is holy: I shall lie down with him in death, and I shall be as dear to him as he to me. Not the living who makes the longest demands. We die forever. You may do ask you like, since apparently the laws of the gods mean nothing to you."
- Antigone's anagnorisis is that she realizes that even though her uncle is the king, he still will not cut her any slack for her trying to bury Polyneices. He will still kill her no matter what. This is shown in paragraph 242. "O city of my fathers in the land of Thebe! O ye gods, eldest of our race!-they lead me henc--now, now-they tarry not! Behold me, princes of Thebes, the last daughter of the house of your kings,-see what I suffer, and from whom, because I feared to cast away the fear of Heaven!"
- Antigone's Peripeteia happens when she kills herself because she knew that the after life would be better than starving in a dark, cold, cave. She knew she was going to die for this crime all along, so rather than suffer. She decided to end her life right away. There was nothing else to live for and she was going to die anyway.
- The audience has a catharsis when Antigone is about to be sent off to the cave where she will starve. The audience is not sure what Creon is going to do with her and it is quite suspenseful. When the audience finds out that she will be sent off to a cave to starve, they feel very bad for her because she was only trying to do good. She does not deserve such harsh punishment because she was staying loyal to her family. This is shown in paragraph 235. "Tomb, bridal-chamber, eternal prison in the caverned rock, whither go to find mine own, those many who have perished, and whom Persephone hath received among the dead!"
- In Antigone, women seem portrayed as weak characters. There appears be the vibe that women cannot do anything on their own and they always need help from men. This is shown in when Haemon says this quote in paragraph 197, "If thou art a woman; indeed, my care is for thee." Even Ismene talks about how women should not fight against men because they would lose. This is shown in paragraph 16. " Nay, we must remember, first, that we were born women, as who should not strive with men;"
Letter to Antigone
My dear sister Antigone,
Please forgive me for not being loyal to the family. I just didn't want to be executed by Creon. Now after giving it much thought, I understand that you just wanted to bury Polyneices in a respectful manner. Even though he was against our own city he was still family, and now I see that I was wrong. I know that Creon will probably execute you, and now I believe it was worth it, to honor our family. I feel absolutely dreadful that I didn’t risk my own life and stand by your side. Instead I coward like a harmless little rabbit being chased by a giant pack of rabid wolves. Our brother should have a proper burial, yet now it is too late for me to fight for it. I was so full of myself that I didn’t even think about the others that were closest to me. Polyneices would have been very proud of you. I wish I could have stuck with you till the very end, but now, I see that it's too late for that. For now, we can only hope for the best, and pray to the gods for their support. Please forgive me for the terrible things I have done, and I am hoping that we'll be able to see each other once more. Till then i bid you farewell.
Love your dearest sister, Ismene.
Please forgive me for not being loyal to the family. I just didn't want to be executed by Creon. Now after giving it much thought, I understand that you just wanted to bury Polyneices in a respectful manner. Even though he was against our own city he was still family, and now I see that I was wrong. I know that Creon will probably execute you, and now I believe it was worth it, to honor our family. I feel absolutely dreadful that I didn’t risk my own life and stand by your side. Instead I coward like a harmless little rabbit being chased by a giant pack of rabid wolves. Our brother should have a proper burial, yet now it is too late for me to fight for it. I was so full of myself that I didn’t even think about the others that were closest to me. Polyneices would have been very proud of you. I wish I could have stuck with you till the very end, but now, I see that it's too late for that. For now, we can only hope for the best, and pray to the gods for their support. Please forgive me for the terrible things I have done, and I am hoping that we'll be able to see each other once more. Till then i bid you farewell.
Love your dearest sister, Ismene.
New Technology
Technology has changed drastically over the passed few years. There have been many new inventions that have been very beneficial for our ever growing economy. Even though our economy is failing in efficiency, we still manage to create new gadgets that are used for pure enjoyment. New technology that is being made is used to make life easier, and more fun. Yet with these two aspects comes much more expense. So you better have some cash or else you wont be able to buy new technology. And when you can't buy new technology, it will become more difficult to make your everyday life more efficient; on the home front that is.
Today I awoke to the smell of fresh toast toasting in the toaster. But i didn't eat any because i don't eat breakfast. I got ready for school and i started out on the home front. I walked down Englewood, which is the most notoriously gangster street in St. Paul, when Ian Hedstrom popped out and gave me quite a fright. We then had ourselves a good old laugh and headed for the bus. We got to school and have had a pretty normal day. Right now I'm sitting in the computer lab of our school with my best gal Celia Byrne. She's one cool cat. And of Course Ella Thomson, the most notorious cooking instructor of all the land. Then there's Ige who is one tough cookie. He's sly like a fox. Thats basic life on the Home Front for you.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
